Which is better bmw 316i manual or nissan x-trail automatic ?

bmw 1600cc manual , x-trail 2500cc automatic 4x4

Which is better bmw 316i manual or nissan x-trail automatic ?computers

you must not be in the united states because here in the u.s. we dont have a 316i or an x trail? sorry

Which is better bmw 316i manual or nissan x-trail automatic ?hijack this

I drove BMWs for the last 14 years whilst living in Germany (although they were all 323i) but I'd say go for the BM, unless you really want to go off road, in which case don't buy an automatic! Actually, don't buy any automatic! Apart from that, your fuel costs will be a lot less with the BM, and if you look after it (regular oil change, occasional Dealer service) it'll give you years of driving pleasure, and probably hold its value better than the Nissan.
I'd have the BMW every time.It looks better,handles better,and is a lot more economical.Unless you really like the look of the Nissan or want to go offroad or towing,Beemer every time.Manual gearboxes are usually less prone to faults too.